Good Fellas Pizzeria

"Good Times. Great Food."

About Us

Welcome to Good Fellas Pizzeria, a beloved Italian restaurant nestled in Streator, IL, that has been serving locals throughout the greater surrounding area since 2006. Our menu is brimming with delectable delights, including mouthwatering pizzas, zesty appetizers, savory wings, hearty Italian beef sandwiches, fresh salads, and a selection of beer and wine. Indulge in our crispy cheese curds, golden french fries, and irresistible desserts. Whether you're looking to pick up a quick meal, have it delivered to your door, or conveniently order online, we've got you covered. Planning a special event? Our catering services and private party options are sure to impress. Join us at Good Fellas Pizzeria for a taste of Italy right here in Illinois!

Areas Served

What We Offer

Our Services include:

Pick-Up, Delivery, and Curbside: Guests can place an order ahead of time and stop by for quick and convenient pick-up, making it an easy option for families, busy schedules, or anyone wanting a meal without the wait. For even more convenience, online ordering & delivery brings menu favorites straight to your door, perfect for weeknights, game days, or relaxing at home.
Gift Certificates: Gift certificates are available for purchase and make a great option for holidays, birthdays, thank-you gifts, or any special occasion. They allow guests to share their favorite pizzas, wings, and menu items with friends and family, offering flexibility to dine in or order out whenever it’s convenient.
Rewards Program: The restaurant offers a simple and rewarding loyalty program that gives guests credit for every visit. Each time a meal is purchased, customers receive a stamp on their loyalty card. After buying ten meals, they receive 15% off the eleventh meal, making it an easy way to earn savings just by enjoying their regular favorites.
Events: The restaurant offers a full range of event services, making it an ideal place to host gatherings of any size. Whether you’re planning a private party, birthday celebration, baby shower, retirement party, or corporate event, the space can be tailored to fit your needs. Catering is also available for both on-site and off-site events, ensuring guests enjoy fresh, crowd-pleasing favorites no matter the occasion. Let the team handle the food and atmosphere while you focus on celebrating with your guests.

Our Brands include:

Canyon Road
Concha Y Toro Cabernet
Merlot

Our Products include:

Pizza
Appetizers
Chicken Wings
Sandwiches
Salads
New Spicy Italian Sandwich!
Beef Rolls
Cheese Curds
Chicken Strips
Fried Mushrooms
Fried Pickles
French Fries
Italian Beef Sandwiches
Meatball Sandwich
Beer
Wine
Desserts
Soda

Testimonials

On 4/4/2026 Erica Ricchiuto had this to say:
We had such a great time at Goodfellas Pizza. They had the Easter Bunny there which was so fun for the kids, and the staff was really sweet and great with them. The food was awesome..especially the pizza special (crab Rangoon pizza). Their pizza is the best around. The owners are super friendly, you can tell they really care about their customers! Overall just a great vibe, great food, and great people. We’ll definitely be back!

On 4/3/2026 Catlover11 had this to say:
Best pizza everrrrr!!!! Everyone is so nice and the pizza is just amazing

On 4/3/2026 Everly had this to say:
Came and tried the beef roll and it’s completely different than any beef roll I’ve tried in the area! So delicious and a buttery garlic flavor rather than just a bunch of cheese. Highly recommend! Testimonial written by Everly on this site.

On 3/28/2026 Emily Hackler had this to say:
This was our first time here and we loved it! The cheese curds were AMAZING! The pizza’s were also really good! We will be back for sure!!

On 3/28/2026 Willow Moss had this to say:
We had a wonderful dinner experience at GoodFellas Pizzeria this Friday evening around 6:30 PM. It was a quieter dine-in night—we were actually the only table at the time—but it gave us a chance to really take in the atmosphere and attention to detail. While dine-in was calm, it was clear their carryout and delivery business was steady and popular. Right away, the cleanliness stood out. Everything was spotless and well-organized, from the bar area—with chairs lined up perfectly and bottles evenly spaced—to the overall dining space. The ambiance is thoughtfully done, with mobster-themed décor throughout the walls that fits the “GoodFellas” vibe perfectly. Even the ceiling, with its unique aged gold tone, adds a lot of character to the space. We started with the fried pickles, and they were fantastic—fresh, hot, and packed with flavor. The real standout alongside them was their house-made ranch. It’s thick, creamy, and clearly made in-house, which made a big difference. For the main course, we ordered pizza, and it did not disappoint. The thin crust was perfectly done—hot, fresh, and well-seasoned. The sauce had a great balance with noticeable herbs that gave it a really rounded flavor. The small pepperonis on the pizza, in particular, had that ideal crisp to it that’s hard to get just right. We also tried the garlic butter, which was very flavorful (though a bit on the runny side), but still a great addition. Even the restrooms deserve a mention—they were 10/10 clean and modern, with a really cool design touch like the glazed exposed brick wall that ties into the overall aesthetic. To top it all off, the staff was friendly and welcoming throughout our visit. As we were leaving, the owner took the time to chat with us and even showed us an original 1930s built-in refrigerator on-site, complete with its original hardware handle. That personal touch really made the experience memorable. Overall, this was a fantastic visit. Between the quality food, clean and unique atmosphere, and genuinely friendly service, GoodFellas Pizzeria is definitely a spot we’ll be returning to—and recommending to others in the Streator area.

Contact Us

Good Fellas Pizzeria
107 N Bloomington St Streator, IL 61364
Phone: (815) 257-1319
Email: goodfellaspizzeriallc@yahoo.com

Where To Find Us

Payment Types Accepted

American Express, Android Pay, Apple Pay, Debit Cards, Discover, MasterCard, Visa, Venmo, Cash App

Our Hours

Wednesday: 5:00 PM - 9:00 PM
Thursday: 5:00 PM - 9:00 PM
Friday: 5:00 PM - 10:00 PM
Saturday: 5:00 PM - 10:00 PM
Sunday: 5:00 PM - 9:00 PM

News

Good Fellas has a stacked lineup for the season! 🙌
👉 Lent Fridays: Enjoy our popular Fish Fry Special, every Friday during Lent.
👉 New Menu Drop: Our Spicy Italian Sandwich—a bold mix of savory meats, melted cheese, and just the right amount of heat.
👉 August 14th: Wreckin’ Dixies Band live—bringing the energy, the music, and the perfect vibe for your night out.
Come hungry. Leave happy. 🍽️🎉

Info

Order Online
Menu

FAQ

What daily specials do you offer currently?

We run new specials every day of the week!

Sunday: Medium 1‑topping pizza $11 • Large 1‑topping pizza $16
Monday: $5 off medium & large beef rolls
Tuesday: $5 off medium & large Italian beef pizza
Wednesday: $2 off crispy chicken salad • $2 off a bottle of wine • Italian beef with fries $9 • $2 domestics
Thursday: Wing Night – All‑you‑can‑eat wings with fries for $18

What types of dining options do you offer?

We offer dine-in, takeout, curbside pick-up and delivery options—making it easy to enjoy your favorite meals wherever you are.

What’s on the menu at Good Fellas?

Our menu features a wide variety including:

▸Handcrafted pizzas 🍕
▸Italian beef sandwiches and hot subs
▸Appetizers like cheese curds, wings, fries
▸Fresh salads
▸Desserts and a selection of beer & wine

Do you offer catering or host private events?

Absolutely! We offer catering services and can accommodate private parties. For more information or to book your event, feel free to call or visit our Contact page.

Does Good Fellas have a rewards program?

Yes! Our loyalty program is simple and rewarding. Each visit earns you a stamp on your loyalty card. After purchasing 10 meals, you’ll receive 15% off your 11th meal, just for enjoying your usual favorites.

Why is there a delivery fee, and do I still need to tip the driver?

Our delivery fee helps cover the overall cost of offering delivery—such as vehicle expenses, insurance, and operations—but this fee does not go to the driver. Because drivers do not receive any portion of the delivery fee, tipping is still appreciated as it goes directly to your driver for providing fast, friendly service. While tips are optional, they help support our drivers and reward them for getting your order to you safely and on time.

Site Navigation